Urological Research Foundation's home page
About the Urological Research Foundation
Prostate Cancer Questions & Answers
Quest Newsletter Articles
Past Quest Publications
Media articles and interviews with Dr. Catalona
Dr. Catalona's journal articles from various publications
Dr. Catalona's genetic research for prostate cancer
Donate to the URF for prostate cancer research
View the New Patient Packet sent by Dr. Catalona
Post-Op Advice for patients
Links to other helpful prostate cancer websites
Litigation Briefs
Contact the Urological Research Foundation



Click here to sign up
for emails from the URF


What is Prostate Cancer
What is Prostate Cancer?



Click here
to request newsletter



Ask the Doctor
Ask the Doctor
Sample Dispute History


 

Patients and research participants continue to ask Dr. Catalona about the details of his dispute with Washington University concerning the blood and tissue samples that they entrusted to him for his research program when he was at Washington University. These samples have become the focus of a legal dispute that lasted almost five years.

Dr. Catalona's Views and Conclusions:

The legal battle lasting nearly 5 years between Washington University (WU) and Dr. William Catalona over ownership of blood and tissue samples has now come to an end at the U.S. Supreme Court when the Court declined to take the case

Dr. Catalona's Views and Conclusions

Petitions for writ of certiorari filed with Supreme Court:

Appeal Briefs On Behalf of Dr. Catalona filed to the United States Court of Appeals for the Eight Circuit:

Dr. Catalona's Response to Public Statements
Posted by Washington University Regarding His Dispute with WU Over Who Has Jurisdiction of Prostate Tissue and Blood Samples
.


Opening Brief for Appellant-Defendents Richard Ward, et al.
This document is the initial appeal brief filed by patient/research participants of Dr. William J. Catalona.


Reply Brief of Appellant-Defendants Richard Ward, et al
This document is the patient/research participants’ (RPs) brief in response to the initial brief filed by Washington University in the Eighth Circuit. The RPs reply brief begins: “…Richard Ward and the other research participants (the RPs) allowed Dr. Catalona to take custody of their blood and tissue samples for the purpose of assisting research into the genetic causes of prostate cancer…the samples are also the literal flesh and blood of the RPs, who have a powerful interest in ensuring that materials taken from their bodies are used in ways that are not ethically objectionable to them….”


Opening Brief for Defendant-Appellant, William J. Catalona, MD
This document is the initial brief filed by Dr. Catalona to the United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit.


Reply Brief of Defendant-Appellant, William J. Catalona, MD
This document is the brief in response to the initial brief filed by Washington University in the Eighth Circuit. William J. Catalona’s reply brief begins: “…Washington University seeks to force upon this Court a false choice between equally extreme positions…”


Amicus Brief of People’s Medical Society
This document is a friend of the court brief filed on behalf of Dr. Catalona and the patient/research participants by a patients rights group.


Amicus Brief of Us Too, International
This document is a friend of the court brief filed on behalf of Dr. Catalona and the patient/research participants by a prostate cancer survivors’group.

Body Snatchers by Michael Crichton (reprinted from Wall Street Journal with permission of the author. All rights reserved)
Michael Crichton writes about Dr. Catalona and his patients' legal fight to regain Dr. Catalona's prostate cancer tissue collection for his and his collaborators research.
Read this article

Litigation Update
Patients, research volunteers, professional colleagues and the news media frequently ask Dr. Catalona about the current status of the litigation of Washington University (WU) vs. his patients and him, concerning the blood and tissue samples he collected during his tenure at WU.
Read this article

Update on Litigation Concerning Research Samples
Dr. Catalona's patients and research participants in his studies conducted when he was at Washington University in St. Louis continue to ask about the status of the litigation in the dispute between Washington University (WU) and Dr. Catalona over the samples that the patients and participants entrusted to Dr. Catalona for use in his collaborative research program.
Read this article

Update on Litigation Concerning Research Samples
Patients and research participants continue to ask Dr. Catalona for updates about the status of the litigation over custody and control of the research samples he collected at Washington University.
Read this article

Update on Litigation Concerning Research Samples
Dr. Catalona’s patients and research participants in his studies continue to ask about the status of the litigation in the dispute between Washington University in St. Louis (WU) and Dr. Catalona regarding the samples that Dr. Catalona’s patients and participants entrusted to him for his research program while at WU.
Read this article

Litigation Update: Spring 2006
Dr. Catalona's patients and research participants from his tenure at Washington University in St. Louis (WU) continue to inquire about the status of the litigation in the dispute between WU and Dr. Catalona regarding the samples that Dr. Catalona's patients and participants entrusted to him for his research program.
Read this article

Litigation Update (as of July 31, 2006)
Dr. Catalona's patients and research participants from his time at Washington University (WU) in St. Louis continue to inquire about the status of the litigation in the dispute between Washington University and Dr. Catalona regarding the samples that Dr. Catalona's patients and participants entrusted to him for his research program.* In March 2006, the District Court Rendered an opinion and Dr. Catalona provides a summary of the case and his views on the opinion.
Read this article


Home    |    About the URF   |    Q & A - Prostate Cancer   |    Quest Articles
Journal Articles   |    National Media   |    Suggested Reading   |    Genetic Research
Donations   |    New Patient Packet   |    Post-Op Advice   |    Helpful Links   |    Contact Us